Shirley's Seafood Restaurant
Dine at a top-rated Exuma seafood spot. Enjoy fresh catches and stunning views. 4.4 stars. Discover authentic Bahamian flavor.
About Shirley's Seafood Restaurant
This beloved island eatery offers a taste of authentic Bahamian seafood, earning a commendable 4.4-star rating from nearly 500 diners. Situated along Queen's Highway, it provides a picturesque setting, perfect for enjoying the fresh ocean breeze and spectacular views. Diners consistently praise the quality of the conch and the warm hospitality, describing the experience as truly amazing. While the menu may be focused, the dishes served are very good, making it a reliable choice for fresh, local flavors in a relaxed atmosphere. With outdoor seating and a welcoming vibe, it's a favorite spot for those seeking genuine island dining.
Restaurant Analysis
Restaurant Characteristics
This restaurant has been analyzed using our formula-based system to help you understand its key features and match it with your dining preferences.
Price Range (Moderate)
Moderate pricing ($$) - Mid-range restaurants with good value
Meal Time (dinner)
This restaurant primarily serves dinner. Based on opening hours.
Group Size (Groups Welcome)
Welcomes large groups and families. Great for group dining.
Atmosphere (Outdoor)
Al fresco dining with outdoor seating
Dining Style (Flexible)
Flexible options. Reservations available but not required.
Features & Amenities
This restaurant offers: Outdoor Seating, Cocktails, Beer, Wine, Family Friendly, Groups Welcome, Reservations
Set your restaurant preferences in your profile to see how well this restaurant matches your dining style.
Why Travelers Love Shirley's Seafood
Sourced from recent guest feedback and verified reviews.
The food and the people are truly amazing! The view is spectacular. You won't find better conch or better people than at this place! Its been a long while since we went but wanted to add my review. My wife and I visited Shirley’s several times on the island, it was one place we knew were open pass 6pm , with not a lot of options around on the island , we were glad we were close by the restaurant, very limited menu , they were out of a few things on our visits , but the food was very good , our servers were very kind , the atmosphere was awesome you could tell those who visit the island often were welcome like family , we always love to eat at local places because of this , and Shirley’s was recommended by a local as really the only local food around , highly recommended. We had a great time at Shirley’s. It’s a laidback place with a relaxed atmosphere, good food, and friendly service. The conch fritters were the highlight—so good that I had to order another round! The seafood mac and cheese was also delicious. My lobster tail was a little on the dry side, but the flavors were still nice. For dessert, I tried the guava pie, which was more of a cheesecake with guava syrup on top—not what I expected! There is no outside seating looking over the water. Overall, a solid spot worth checking out!
Find the Restaurant
Where to Find Them
Opening Hours
Sign in to boost this restaurant with your daily points
Sign In to PromoteInstant Boost Packages
One-time purchase — points apply immediately to this restaurant
💡 Tip: Subscriptions are 90% cheaper per point!
Recent Reviews
Amie E.
June 9, 2025
The food and the people are truly amazing! The view is spectacular. You won't find better conch or better people than at this place! Its been a long while since we went but wanted to add my review.
Gabriel D.
July 29, 2025
My wife and I visited Shirley’s several times on the island, it was one place we knew were open pass 6pm , with not a lot of options around on the island , we were glad we were close by the restaurant, very limited menu , they were out of a few things on our visits , but the food was very good , our servers were very kind , the atmosphere was awesome you could tell those who visit the island often were welcome like family , we always love to eat at local places because of this , and Shirley’s was recommended by a local as really the only local food around , highly recommended.
Alyona R.
February 27, 2025
We had a great time at Shirley’s. It’s a laidback place with a relaxed atmosphere, good food, and friendly service. The conch fritters were the highlight—so good that I had to order another round! The seafood mac and cheese was also delicious. My lobster tail was a little on the dry side, but the flavors were still nice. For dessert, I tried the guava pie, which was more of a cheesecake with guava syrup on top—not what I expected! There is no outside seating looking over the water. Overall, a solid spot worth checking out!
Aimee S.
June 8, 2024
We went to Shirley’s twice on our visit to Exuma. The first time was at about 4:30 and we were offered the lunch and dinner menu. We tried the conch fingers, seafood Po’Boy and the fried snapper. All were amazing and made even better because of our awesome server, “G”. It was a fabulous experience, so good that we went back the next evening which was a Sunday and we had read that a lot of places were closed. This time we had the dinner menu and a different server. This meal we had the conch fritters, fried grouper and lobster Mac and cheese, and the conch curry as well as the guava pie. This meal was very disappointing all the way around. I also tried the goombay punch the Shirley’s Breeze? Cocktail, both of which were overrated in my opinion. They have a huge pile of conch shells out back and G said we could go out there and pick them up for free if we wanted. So long story short, go for lunch and make sure you ask for G to be your server.
Cali S.
July 29, 2025
We found Shirley’s after a long day of travel and it was one of the few places still open. Tia was our waitress and she was very attentive and kind. The food was wonderful, though there are not a lot of menu options. Everything we ordered was very good. The conch chowder and conch fritters were some of our favorite items. Tia and G shared with us all the things we should see on the island and even told us about a summer festival going on that we went to after dinner. They were so welcoming and a delight to talk to. If you’re looking for a place to eat, Shirley’s is a great option!
What to Expect
Features and amenities that make Shirley's Seafood special
Outdoor Seating
Cocktails
Beer
Wine
Family Friendly
Groups Welcome
Reservations
Practical Information
Everything you need to know before you visit
Payment Options
Parking
Accessibility
Other Popular Restaurants in Exuma
Build your own culinary trail—save these spots for future nights out in Exuma.
The Hill House Restaurant at Fowl Cay Resort
Tropic Breeze
Sandpiper Cafe
Shallow Waters Bar & Restaurant
Sistah's Place
Exuma Point Beach Resort Restaurant
VIBE Exuma
Emerald Sunset View
Cocoplum Bistro, Exuma
Santanna's Bar & Grill
Coconut Club
Rusty Anchor
Blu on the Water Restaurant & Bar
Eddie's Edgewater
Salt Resto Bar
Chat 'N' Chill Beach Bar & Grill
Blue Conch Restaurant and Bar
Tim's on the Bay
Splash Beach Bar
Plan Your Exuma Trip
From transportation to stays, we help you build a complete itinerary around this must-visit restaurant in Exuma.
Transportation Tips
Use organized boat tours, rent a boat, or take water taxis between islands. Many tours include transportation and equipment.
Car Rental Deals in Exuma
Rent a car for maximum flexibility and explore at your own pace on Expedia USA.
Where to Stay
Find the perfect accommodation for your Exuma adventure. From luxury beachfront resorts to boutique hideaways, we highlight the best basecamps for food lovers.
Best Hotel Deals in Exuma
Discover top-rated hotels with exclusive rates and special offers on Expedia USA.
Popular Tours in Exuma
Pair dinner at Shirley's Seafood with these top-rated experiences in Exuma.